Edinburgh Fringe Feature: Summerhall 2012 / Teatr Piesn Kozla & Fringe highlights

Saviour of the Fringe

In 2010 producer Rupert Thomson set out to save the artistic integrity of the Edinburgh Fringe. Now his Summerhall project is bringing some of Europe’s best theatre back to the festival, writes Mark Brown

Two years ago a young Edinburgh theatre producer by the name of Rupert Thomson wrote an article entitled ‘Save the Festival, Axe the Fringe’. In that piece he argued that a combination of a rise in commercialisation and a decline in artistic quality on the Fringe was threatening Edinburgh’s position as the world’s pre-eminent festival city.

He gave as an example his experience with an Italian theatre company he had shown around Edinburgh with a view to putting their work on at the Fringe. “They were keen to come”, he wrote, “but eventually decided that the festival – and the Fringe in particular – ‘didn’t feel right’: not enough serious theatre, too much comedy, too much emphasis on money.”

One year on from that article, Thomson was putting his money, or, at least his considerable energy, where his mouth was. The Summerhall building (formerly the comically named Royal Dick Vet School), on the southside of the city, was being sold by Edinburgh University. Thomson spotted an opportunity, in the midst of the building’s sale, to turn it into a temporary Fringe venue.

The resulting, hastily created Summerhall 2011 programme was a great success. Headlined by the well-received, through-the-night Brazilian-British co-production Hotel Medea, the work Thomson staged lived up to his stated intention to present high-quality, international work which had artistic, rather than commercial, imperatives at its heart.

Now, with the backing of the building’s new proprietor, Robert McDowell, Thomson has turned Summerhall into a permanent arts centre with an impressively extensive Fringe programme. Inevitably, given both its ethos and the nature of the carefully curated work it is presenting, the Summerhall Fringe programme finds itself compared with Aurora Nova, the acclaimed visual theatre festival-within-the-festival which ran at St Stephen’s church from 2001 until 2007.

“Aurora Nova was inspirational”, Thomson tells me. “Not only in the work that it presented, but also in the way it went about its business. The support it gave to artists was very important, because the Fringe is a big market place.

“That, of course, is part of its value, but it also means that it will naturally have a commercial edge, which needs to be resisted quite consciously if it’s not to take over. We are less motivated by commercial imperatives, even though, of course, we’ve got to think practically. We’ve got a bar and café, and we want lots of people coming in and having fun. But the main thing is to facilitate the best quality work we can.”

One of the companies attracted to Summerhall by Thomson’s ethics and advocacy is Teatr Pieśń Kozła (Song of the Goat Theatre), a group from Wrocław in Poland. Well known to Aurora Nova audiences as creators of the extraordinary shows Chronicles – A Lamentation and Lacrimosa, the company had declared that they would not be returning to the Fringe following their last visit in 2007.

“I chose to come to come back to Edinburgh because I met Rupert from the Summerhall venue”, says TPK’s artistic director Grzegorz Bral. “He explained to me that there is a big desire among many people in Edinburgh to change the Festival Fringe into something which is significant once again, rather than just being thousands of stand-up comedians and insignificant art. I trusted him when he said ‘please come, because the Festival needs people who are honestly searching for a profound theatre.’”

There can be no doubting the profundity or the artistic quality of the two shows which TPK are bringing to Summerhall next month. Macbeth (August 9-11) and Songs Of Lear (August 12-24) bring the group’s very particular aesthetic (which is inspired by the Polish theatre master Jerzy Grotowski) to bear on two of Shakespeare’s greatest tragedies.

I saw the older of the two pieces, Macbeth, at TPK’s own theatre, a former nun’s refectory in a 14th-century monastery in Wrocław, in 2009. At that point, it was a fascinatingly physical production, full of beautiful, typically Caravaggesque imagery, and drawing on the Bard’s script in a selective way which gave it a different, and intriguing shape.

“I can only say that Macbeth is much more mature than when we toured it in England in 2010”, comments Bral. “It is much more condensed, and much more emotionally powerful.”

The newer work, Songs Of Lear, dispenses with Shakespeare’s dialogue in favour of a deeply emotionally affecting, indeed spiritual, performance of polyphonic song. “The performance we have created is almost in the form of an oratorio”, says Bral.

“It has numerous songs which take us through the story of King Lear. There is no linear narration, there is no text. Instead, the piece is constructed entirely of songs which operate like small, dramatic poems. Each song is a small performance.”

The songs, of which there are 12, have been written by two composers, JeanClaude Acquaviva from Corsica, and Maciej Rychly from Poland. Acquaviva’s songs stand in the tradition of “liturgical polyphony”, Bral explains. Rychly’s have their roots in the Fifth, so-called “Heretic”, Gospel of Saint Thomas (also known as “Doubting Thomas”), which was discovered in Egypt in 1945 and is written in the Egyptian Coptic language. Consequently, Rychly has composed his songs in Coptic.

“One music represents the court, the kingdom and the harmony of the play”, the director comments. “The other, Coptic music brings the break in the harmony, the tragedy of the drama. It introduces the audience to the dark energies in the play when King Lear decides to divide his kingdom between two of his daughters.”

That, one suspects, will be music to the ears of those who long for a more artistic Edinburgh Fringe. Bral, like Thomson, could prove to be part of a revolution which drives the moneylenders from the temple.

For further information about the Summerhall Fringe programme, visit: http://www.summerhall.co.uk


Mr Carmen

St Petersburg company AKHE – self-styled makers of “Russian Engineering Theatre” and creators of Edinburgh Fringe successes Pooh & Prah (2001) and White Cabin (2003) – specialise in a sometimes mysterious, sometimes hilarious theatre of images. Their highly physical work carries a resonating power, both psychologically and emotionally. In Mr Carmen, they turn their wonderfully tangential imaginations to Prosper Mérimée’s famous novella (which spawned Bizet’s even more famous opera). Bringing the hero face-to-face with his alter-ego, the piece promises to be a stunning, existentialist exploration of the desire for death, and the validation of life.

Assembly Roxy, Edinburgh, August 2-27


Statements After An Arrest Under The Immorality Act

The Fugard Theatre of Cape Town presents great South African dramatist Athol Fugard’s play about an illegal love affair between a white woman and a black man during apartheid. The lovers meet and make love in the library where the woman works, until they are arrested under the racist regime’s infamous Immorality Act.Fugard, author of such classic plays as Sizwe Bansi Is Dead and The Island, writes with the political purpose of Brecht and the naturalistic power of Ibsen. An emotive afternoon’s theatre is in prospect.

Assembly Hall, Edinburgh, August 2-27


Continuous Growth

Another collaboration between Finnish companies Ryhmateatteri (The Group Theatre) and Ace Production and an ensemble of Scotland-based actors, led by the superb Billy Mack (collectively, creators of last year’s Fringe hit production of Gogol’s The Overcoat). Written by Finnish dramatists Esa Leskinenand Sami Keski-Vähälä, and adapted by Catherine Grosvenor, the play promises to be a contemporary, Gogolian satire of the capitalist crisis. Mack plays Andy, a brilliant engineer whose very inventiveness, far from rewarding him, sends him on a downward spiral. Faced with destitution, he invents the ultimate capitalist machine, the automatic healthcare system!

Pleasance Dome, Edinburgh, August 1-27



The world première of the latest play by Simon Stephens, author of the excellent and disturbing Pornography, presented at the Traverse by the Lyric Hammersmith. Two friends leave each other following an encounter which will transform their lives. Described as “a dark coming of age play”, the piece promises to carry the penetrating, thoughtful writing that has come to characterise Stephens’s dramas. Directed by the Lyric’s artistic director Sean Holmes (award-winning director of Sarah Kane’s Blasted and Edward Bond’s Saved), it should be a memorable production.

Traverse, Edinburgh, August 1-19

This feature was originally published in the Sunday Herald on July 29, 2012

© Mark Brown


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s