Reviews: Aganeza Scrooge (Tron, Glasgow) & Too Many Penguins? (Traverse, Edinburgh)



Aganeza Scrooge

Tron, Glasgow

Until January 5


Too Many Penguins?

Traverse, Edinburgh

Until December 22


Reviewed by Mark Brown


Since the turn of the millennium, when Forbes Masson penned legendary shows such as Aladdie and Weans In The Wood, Glasgow’s Tron Theatre has been the undisputed home of the Scottish pastiche pantomime. There is a certain inevitability, therefore, in Johnny McKnight’s arrival as the writer, director and, let’s face it, glittering star of the Clydeside playhouse’s latest festive show.

McKnight made his name as a pantomime creator and performer at the MacRobert Arts Centre in Stirling. This year he has written three pantos, with productions at the Lyceum, Edinburgh and the MacBob, as well as this show at the Tron.

His Aganeza Scrooge relocates Dickens’ A Christmas Carol to Glasgow with a wonderfully absurd contempt for historical accuracy and continuity. Comparing this hilarious and raucous night out with the rather flat production being staged at the Lyceum, one realises that, more than McKnight’s writing, it is his outrageous stage persona which accounts for his yuletide success.

On press night at the Tron, I suffered for my less-than-enthusiastic review of the Lyceum show. As Aganeza (McKnight in a gloriously ridiculous costume, all padding, psychedelic colours and hair that looks like it’s been designed by Sue Ellen from Dallas) made her way down the auditorium stairs, yours truly was selected to have the fragrant lead sit on his lap with all the delicacy of George Galloway at a feminist conference.

When he’s not sitting on theatre critics, McKnight is leading a brilliant cast; including Sally Reid as a very funny Tiny Tim, among others, and Darren Brownlie, camper than Christmas in various roles. The show is cleverly pitched, as Tron pantos have to be, to entertain adults and children alike. The only question is why, during the vision of pantos yet to come, is poor Tiny Tim blessed to be wearing a shirt of Paisley’s pride, the Stars in Stripes, current League Cup semi-finalists St Mirren FC?

Talking of brilliance in black and white, Frozen Charlotte theatre company’s award-winning Too Many Penguins? makes a welcome return, transferring from the MacRobert (where it premiered last Christmas) to the Traverse. I missed the show last year, due to a weather-related cancellation. Catching it now, it isn’t difficult to see why it garnered so much critical acclaim.

The show, in which Mr Polaro is inundated with penguins (thanks to the gregariousness of his neighbour Penguina), is a charmingly off-beat piece of theatre for children aged one to four. Adults of a zoological bent might point out that Mr Polaro is bound to be annoyed by the arrival of the penguins, given that polar bears live in the Arctic and penguins in Antarctica. However, that geographical conundrum is far less perplexing than the question of exactly how the little flightless birds (represented by a host of delightful soft toys) manage to get into every nook and cranny of Mr Polaro’s house.

Joe Douglas and Nicola Jo Cully give beautifully gentle-yet-lively performances as, respectively, Mr Polaro and Penguina. Director Heather Fulton’s production is also blessed with a lovely set and half-creature/half-human costume designs by Katy Wilson.

It seems almost churlish to find fault in this lovely little show, but if it lacks anything it is, for much of the show, interactivity. For sure, the children are thoroughly involved at the end, when they borrow a penguin for a lovely moment of avian dancing. However, for too long the kids are required to simply watch, like a conventional, older audience. Funny and fascinating though the popping up of the penguins is, it isn’t quite a substitute for the start-to-finish interactivity achieved by, for example, early years theatre masters Oily Cart.

These reviews were originally published in the Sunday Herald on December 16, 2012

© Mark Brown


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s